Mayor Pingree Red Label Bourbon
Mayor

Mayor Pingree Red Label Bourbon

User-/100
Expert60/100
Fair Price-
Locations-
MSRP-
Auction-

Overview
Mayor Pingree Red Label Bourbon is a small batch release from Valentine Distilling Co., which built a devoted following after selling out completely for two years. Its return marks an improved expression, delivering balanced flavors that surpass expectations for a young bourbon.

Specs at a glance

DetailInfo
StyleSmall Batch Bourbon
ABVNot specified
MashbillNot specified
Release InfoSold out for two years; returned enhanced [#1][#2]
AgeYoung (NAS) [#2]

Good to know
Produced by Valentine Distilling Co. in small batches, this Red Label variant quickly became a cult favorite, leading to extended unavailability. Expert reviewers note its thoughtful production elevates it beyond typical young bourbons, with enhancements upon relaunch earning strong praise for overall quality.

Tasting notes

  • Nose: Inviting profile noted for depth uncommon in young releases.
  • Palate: Balanced flavors shine, with thoughtful maturation yielding harmony that impresses reviewers.
  • Finish: Lingering balance reflects the distillery's careful craftsmanship.

Notable details

  • Production: Small batch process emphasizes quality control [#1][#2].
  • Lineage: Valentine Distilling Co. flagship offering under the Mayor Pingree label.
  • Availability: Previously unavailable for two years; now back on market [#1].

"After literally selling out for 2 years, Mayor Pingree Red Label has returned better than ever." – The Bourbon Culture [#1]

Closing
A craft bourbon that rewards patience, ideal for enthusiasts seeking refined young whiskey with proven appeal.


Sources

[1] Thebourbonculture – "Mayor Pingree Small Batch Red Label Bourbon Review"

[2] Thebourbonculture – "Mayor Pingree Small Batch Red Label Bourbon Review"

© 2026 Potion. Explore Responsibly.